The Truth About Variable Universal Life and the Scam Narrative

Sarah Davis
April 21st, 2025

Variable Universal Life insurance has become one of the most controversial products in financial planning. Mention it in a room of advisors or clients and reactions are immediate. Skepticism.

Dismissal. Sometimes outright hostility.

That reaction did not come out of nowhere. But it is also not the full truth.

Variable Universal Life is not a scam. It is a powerful tool that has been misunderstood, oversold, and misused. And when expectations are set incorrectly, consequences follow.

At Texas Life Group, this product is never introduced casually. It demands clarity, discipline, and honesty from both the advisor and the client.

How the Scam Narrative Started

Variable Universal Life places market risk directly on the policyholder. Cash value is invested in market based subaccounts and fluctuates with performance. There are no guarantees protecting against volatility.

In the past, many policies were sold using optimistic projections, minimal funding, and little discussion of downside risk. When markets declined or underperformed expectations, policy costs rose, cash values fell, and some policies required additional contributions to stay in force.

Clients felt blindsided. Trust eroded. The product took the blame.

But markets behave exactly as markets do. The real failure was not the structure. It was the promise.

Texas Life Group regularly reviews existing policies where the issue was never Variable Universal Life itself, but how it was positioned and maintained.

The Unpopular Truth About Why It Still Exists

If Variable Universal Life were fundamentally flawed, it would not have survived regulatory scrutiny, market cycles, and decades of use.

The reason it still exists is simple. When designed conservatively, funded properly, and actively monitored, it can do things other insurance products cannot.

It offers access to market driven growth inside an insurance structure. It provides flexibility in premiums and investment allocation. It allows long term accumulation potential for individuals who already understand volatility and accept it elsewhere in their financial lives.

The mistake is pretending it is something it is not.

At Texas Life Group, assumptions are stress tested, funding is intentional, and expectations are set before policies are implemented.

Who Should Never Own Variable Universal Life

Variable Universal Life is not appropriate for everyone. It is not designed for individuals who want guarantees, minimal involvement, or certainty of outcomes regardless of market conditions.

It is not suitable for those who would be financially strained by additional funding requirements or uncomfortable with fluctuations in account value.

Saying no is part of responsible planning. Texas Life Group declines more Variable Universal Life cases than it accepts, because suitability matters more than sales.

Who It Can Work For and Why That Bothers People

For high income earners, business owners, and families with strong cash flow and long planning horizons, Variable Universal Life can serve a strategic role.

These individuals already accept market exposure in other areas of their financial lives. They value flexibility. They understand that long term outcomes are shaped by discipline and oversight rather than guarantees.

When expectations align with reality, Variable Universal Life can function as intended.

Texas Life Group works with clients who want transparency over comfort and strategy over slogans.

The Real Reason This Product Is Still Misunderstood

It is easier to dismiss a complex tool than to explain it honestly.

Variable Universal Life forces difficult conversations about risk, funding, oversight, and expectations. Many advisors avoid those conversations. Some clients prefer to avoid them too.

But avoiding reality does not make it disappear.

Texas Life Group believes clarity is more respectful than comfort.

Final Thought

Variable Universal Life insurance is not a scam. It is not a shortcut either.

It is a sophisticated tool that rewards understanding and punishes neglect. For the wrong person, it fails loudly.

For the right person, properly structured and responsibly managed, it can work quietly for

decades.

The controversy exists because honesty is harder than hype.

Sarah Davis
April 21st, 2025

Recent Blogs

When Money Complicates Family

Money has a way of changing family dynamics, even in families that are otherwise close and well intentioned.
Amanda
Dec 15th, 2025

Why Automation Hasn’t Replaced Advisors

Automation has reshaped financial services. Portfolios rebalance automatically.
Matthew
Nov 19th, 2025

Recessions Don’t Create Problems—They Expose Them

Recessions rarely arrive as a single moment. They emerge gradually, often after long periods of confidence and expansion.
Ashley
Oct 28th, 2025